Critically Acclaimed PC Games

Steam games with a Metacritic score of 85 or higher, shown alongside their Steam player review percentage. The gap column highlights titles where critics and players disagree.
# Game Year Metacritic Steam users Gap Reviews
51 2010 91 Universal Acclaim 96% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +5 89,030
52
Dishonored
Dishonored
Action, Adventure
2012 91 Universal Acclaim 98% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +7 88,961
53 2012 91 Universal Acclaim 96% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +5 79,264
54 2026 91 Universal Acclaim 79% Mostly Positive Critics +12 73,524
55
TEKKEN 8
TEKKEN 8
Action
2024 91 Universal Acclaim 57% Mixed Critics +34 73,503
56 2009 91 Universal Acclaim 82% Positive Critics +9 56,468
57
DARK SOULS™ II
DARK SOULS™ II
Action, RPG
2014 91 Universal Acclaim 88% Very Positive Agree 47,029
58
Big Walk
Big Walk
Adventure
2026 91 Universal Acclaim 96% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +5 46,118
59
Against the Storm
Against the Storm
Simulation, Strategy
2023 91 Universal Acclaim 94% Very Positive Agree 37,922
60 2010 91 Universal Acclaim 86% Very Positive Critics +5 31,745
61 2013 91 Universal Acclaim 92% Very Positive Agree 30,172
62
Fallout 3
Fallout 3
RPG
2008 91 Universal Acclaim 81% Positive Critics +10 22,228
63
Spelunky 2
Spelunky 2
Action, Indie
2020 91 Universal Acclaim 93% Very Positive Agree 22,090
64
FEZ
FEZ
Indie
2013 91 Universal Acclaim 93% Very Positive Agree 16,346
65
Mark of the Ninja
Mark of the Ninja
Action, Adventure, Indie
— 91 Universal Acclaim 97% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +6 15,875
66
Crysis
Crysis
Action
2008 91 Universal Acclaim 80% Positive Critics +11 13,428
67
Caves of Qud
Caves of Qud
Adventure, Indie, RPG, Strategy
2024 91 Universal Acclaim 95% Overwhelmingly Positive Agree 12,810
68
Chained Echoes
Chained Echoes
Indie, RPG
2022 91 Universal Acclaim 89% Very Positive Agree 8,292
69 2006 91 Universal Acclaim 95% Overwhelmingly Positive Agree 7,934
70
UFO 50
UFO 50
Action, Adventure, Indie, RPG, Strategy
2024 91 Universal Acclaim 95% Overwhelmingly Positive Agree 7,585
71
Scarlet Hollow
Scarlet Hollow
Adventure, Casual, Indie, RPG, Early Access
2021 91 Universal Acclaim 98% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +7 5,438
72
I Was a Teenage Exocolonist
I Was a Teenage Exocolonist
Indie, RPG, Simulation
2022 91 Universal Acclaim 96% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +5 4,916
73 2008 91 Universal Acclaim 88% Very Positive Agree 4,091
74 2009 91 Universal Acclaim 81% Positive Critics +10 2,277
75
The Longest Journey
The Longest Journey
Action, Adventure, RPG
2007 91 Universal Acclaim 90% Very Positive Agree 2,195
76
Batman: Arkham City
Batman: Arkham City
Action, Adventure
2011 91 Universal Acclaim 98% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +7 2,152
77
Tumblestone
Tumblestone
Action, Casual, Indie, Strategy
2016 91 Universal Acclaim 77% Mostly Positive Critics +14 1,974
78
BZZZT
BZZZT
Action, Indie
2023 91 Universal Acclaim 94% Very Positive Agree 1,191
79 2009 91 Universal Acclaim 67% Mixed Critics +24 538
80
Freespace 2
Freespace 2
Action
2014 91 Universal Acclaim 79% Mostly Positive Critics +12 323
81
Mission: It's Complicated
Mission: It's Complicated
Adventure, Casual, Indie
2020 91 Universal Acclaim 92% Very Positive Agree 241
82
Dota 2
Dota 2
Action, Strategy, Free To Play
2013 90 Universal Acclaim 80% Positive Critics +10 2,810,095
83
Hollow Knight: Silksong
Hollow Knight: Silksong
Action, Adventure, Indie
2025 90 Universal Acclaim 90% Very Positive Agree 427,482
84
Factorio
Factorio
Casual, Indie, Simulation, Strategy
2020 90 Universal Acclaim 98% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +8 236,793
85 2010 90 Universal Acclaim 96% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +6 211,256
86 2020 90 Universal Acclaim 83% Positive Critics +7 207,458
87
Portal
Portal
Action
2007 90 Universal Acclaim 99% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +9 201,206
88
Balatro
Balatro
Casual, Indie, Strategy
2024 90 Universal Acclaim 98% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +8 201,055
89
DAVE THE DIVER
DAVE THE DIVER
Adventure, Casual, RPG, Simulation
2023 90 Universal Acclaim 96% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +6 164,826
90 — 90 Universal Acclaim 90% Very Positive Agree 69,765
91
God of War Ragnarök
God of War Ragnarök
Action, Adventure, RPG
2024 90 Universal Acclaim 89% Very Positive Agree 51,381
92
Brothers - A Tale of Two Sons
Brothers - A Tale of Two Sons
Action, Adventure, Indie
2013 90 Universal Acclaim 94% Very Positive Agree 41,282
93 2007 90 Universal Acclaim 97% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +7 41,162
94 2009 90 Universal Acclaim 91% Very Positive Agree 38,366
95
Hi-Fi RUSH
Hi-Fi RUSH
Action
2023 90 Universal Acclaim 97% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +7 36,146
96
Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut
Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut
Adventure, Indie, RPG, Simulation
2023 90 Universal Acclaim 97% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +7 35,466
97
Bayonetta
Bayonetta
Action, Adventure
2017 90 Universal Acclaim 92% Very Positive Agree 33,000
98
Guild Wars 2®
Guild Wars 2®
Adventure, Massively Multiplayer, RPG, Free To Play
2022 90 Universal Acclaim 88% Very Positive Agree 30,191
99
ANIMAL WELL
ANIMAL WELL
Action, Adventure, Indie
2024 90 Universal Acclaim 96% Overwhelmingly Positive Players +6 24,862
100
Into the Breach
Into the Breach
Indie, RPG, Simulation, Strategy
2018 90 Universal Acclaim 94% Very Positive Agree 22,556
Page 2 of 11