| # | Game | Year | Metacritic | Steam users | Gap | Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 51 | Batman: Arkham Asylum Game of the Year Edition Action, Adventure | 2010 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 96% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +5 | 89,030 |
| 52 | Dishonored Action, Adventure | 2012 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 98% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +7 | 88,961 |
| 53 | Batman: Arkham City - Game of the Year Edition Action, Adventure | 2012 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 96% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +5 | 79,264 |
| 54 | 2026 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 79% Mostly Positive | Critics +12 | 73,524 | |
| 55 | TEKKEN 8 Action | 2024 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 57% Mixed | Critics +34 | 73,503 |
| 56 | 2009 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 82% Positive | Critics +9 | 56,468 | |
| 57 | DARK SOULS™ II Action, RPG | 2014 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 88% Very Positive | Agree | 47,029 |
| 58 | Big Walk Adventure | 2026 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 96% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +5 | 46,118 |
| 59 | Against the Storm Simulation, Strategy | 2023 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 94% Very Positive | Agree | 37,922 |
| 60 | 2010 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 86% Very Positive | Critics +5 | 31,745 | |
| 61 | Deus Ex: Human Revolution - Director's Cut Action, RPG | 2013 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 92% Very Positive | Agree | 30,172 |
| 62 | Fallout 3 RPG | 2008 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 81% Positive | Critics +10 | 22,228 |
| 63 | Spelunky 2 Action, Indie | 2020 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 93% Very Positive | Agree | 22,090 |
| 64 | FEZ Indie | 2013 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 93% Very Positive | Agree | 16,346 |
| 65 | Mark of the Ninja Action, Adventure, Indie | — | 91 Universal Acclaim | 97% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +6 | 15,875 |
| 66 | Crysis Action | 2008 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 80% Positive | Critics +11 | 13,428 |
| 67 | Caves of Qud Adventure, Indie, RPG, Strategy | 2024 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 95% Overwhelmingly Positive | Agree | 12,810 |
| 68 | Chained Echoes Indie, RPG | 2022 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 89% Very Positive | Agree | 8,292 |
| 69 | Call of Duty® (2003) Action | 2006 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 95% Overwhelmingly Positive | Agree | 7,934 |
| 70 | UFO 50 Action, Adventure, Indie, RPG, Strategy | 2024 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 95% Overwhelmingly Positive | Agree | 7,585 |
| 71 | Scarlet Hollow Adventure, Casual, Indie, RPG, Early Access | 2021 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 98% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +7 | 5,438 |
| 72 | I Was a Teenage Exocolonist Indie, RPG, Simulation | 2022 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 96% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +5 | 4,916 |
| 73 | Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell® Action | 2008 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 88% Very Positive | Agree | 4,091 |
| 74 | 2009 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 81% Positive | Critics +10 | 2,277 | |
| 75 | The Longest Journey Action, Adventure, RPG | 2007 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 90% Very Positive | Agree | 2,195 |
| 76 | Batman: Arkham City Action, Adventure | 2011 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 98% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +7 | 2,152 |
| 77 | Tumblestone Action, Casual, Indie, Strategy | 2016 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 77% Mostly Positive | Critics +14 | 1,974 |
| 78 | BZZZT Action, Indie | 2023 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 94% Very Positive | Agree | 1,191 |
| 79 | Street Fighter® IV Action | 2009 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 67% Mixed | Critics +24 | 538 |
| 80 | Freespace 2 Action | 2014 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 79% Mostly Positive | Critics +12 | 323 |
| 81 | Mission: It's Complicated Adventure, Casual, Indie | 2020 | 91 Universal Acclaim | 92% Very Positive | Agree | 241 |
| 82 | Dota 2 Action, Strategy, Free To Play | 2013 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 80% Positive | Critics +10 | 2,810,095 |
| 83 | Hollow Knight: Silksong Action, Adventure, Indie | 2025 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 90% Very Positive | Agree | 427,482 |
| 84 | Factorio Casual, Indie, Simulation, Strategy | 2020 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 98% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +8 | 236,793 |
| 85 | Sid Meier's Civilization® V Strategy | 2010 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 96% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +6 | 211,256 |
| 86 | Grand Theft Auto IV: The Complete Edition Action, Adventure | 2020 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 83% Positive | Critics +7 | 207,458 |
| 87 | Portal Action | 2007 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 99% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +9 | 201,206 |
| 88 | Balatro Casual, Indie, Strategy | 2024 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 98% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +8 | 201,055 |
| 89 | DAVE THE DIVER Adventure, Casual, RPG, Simulation | 2023 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 96% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +6 | 164,826 |
| 90 | Total War: SHOGUN 2 Strategy | — | 90 Universal Acclaim | 90% Very Positive | Agree | 69,765 |
| 91 | God of War Ragnarök Action, Adventure, RPG | 2024 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 89% Very Positive | Agree | 51,381 |
| 92 | Brothers - A Tale of Two Sons Action, Adventure, Indie | 2013 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 94% Very Positive | Agree | 41,282 |
| 93 | Half-Life 2: Episode Two Action | 2007 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 97% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +7 | 41,162 |
| 94 | 2009 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 91% Very Positive | Agree | 38,366 | |
| 95 | Hi-Fi RUSH Action | 2023 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 97% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +7 | 36,146 |
| 96 | Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut Adventure, Indie, RPG, Simulation | 2023 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 97% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +7 | 35,466 |
| 97 | Bayonetta Action, Adventure | 2017 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 92% Very Positive | Agree | 33,000 |
| 98 | Guild Wars 2® Adventure, Massively Multiplayer, RPG, Free To Play | 2022 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 88% Very Positive | Agree | 30,191 |
| 99 | ANIMAL WELL Action, Adventure, Indie | 2024 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 96% Overwhelmingly Positive | Players +6 | 24,862 |
| 100 | Into the Breach Indie, RPG, Simulation, Strategy | 2018 | 90 Universal Acclaim | 94% Very Positive | Agree | 22,556 |